VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Patronus
Via Militera Clan
Via Militera Clan
User avatar
Posts: 432
Joined: 01 May 2015 10:28
Has thanked: 673 times
Been thanked: 142 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby Patronus » 06 Sep 2015 19:29

Dedline September 13
rules
Bo5


First attacks VM Stradomski

VM Stradomski http://steamcommunity.com/id/stradomski :Tylis: :Pont: :Siracusi: :Carth: :get:
WOLF Diplomatt http://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561198019070908/ :Tylis: :Pont: :Siracusi: :parth: :suebi:

GL HF!
Awards
ImageImage

Stradomski
Via Militera Clan
Via Militera Clan
Posts: 15
Joined: 27 Jun 2015 11:01
Has thanked: 3 times
Been thanked: 17 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby Stradomski » 16 Sep 2015 18:35

Я в лесу, но я там ничего не скрываю. Что здесь не так? Я не англо говорящий, по сему действую в соответствии с русской версией правил.

Кстати, чой-то ты к вольфам подлизываться пришёл?) У тебя вроде свой матч есть нифига не сыгранный.

P.S. факт, что игра помечает мои отряды, как находящие в лесу, ещё проверить надо(если бы помечала - их бы не было видно). Но только вот это не имеет отношения к делу.
Awards
Image

The True Legend
Victory or Death Clan
Victory or Death Clan
User avatar
Posts: 183
Joined: 07 May 2015 03:40
Has thanked: 16 times
Been thanked: 70 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby The True Legend » 16 Sep 2015 19:02

You cant just quit a game when things arent going your way. If he violated rules, as per rules, you must point it out to stradomski and inform him to move out. Speaking of violation, Stradomski didnt do anything wrong by placing his units there. He didnt cover his units in the trees as you can clearly see 90% of his troops out of the trees. Clearly more than 3/4 of his troops were visible.


P.S. that rule was only made up bcuz more than 3/4 were completely hidden in the trees in an atw battle.
The strong is never disturbed by the weak!

Winner of 5 Big Events & #11 in the Rome 2 Leaderboard!!

Administrator at the VODCA Steam Group. Join the Group and Fight for you own Glory!
My Awards
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
ImageImage
Image
Image


Complete Tournament Achievements(R2&ATW)
Rome 2:
1rstThe Last Stand (32)
1rstSons of Macedon (32)
1rstWrath of Barbs (16)
1rstSoutheast Arc (34)
1rstGladiators League S07 (20)
1rstUnit Ban Beta (23)
1rstVODCA R2 Flash#2 (15)
1rstUse it, Lose it (64) (both finalists winners)
2ndWOLF Flash#8 (16)
FinalsNAFT#2 (13) (kicked out by host after beating him)
Semi-FinalsComrade's 2v2 Team Tourny (16) (died out)
Top 8CON 2015 with Epirus(!!!)

Attila:
1rstNAFT July (16)
2ndVODCA ATW Flash#5
3rdBlood and Sand (32)
3rdWind Of Changes (32)
3rdTWCL Winter 2015 (24)
3rdODM Flash#1 (21)
Semi-FinalsUnit Ban Alpha (16) (died out)

Olkimos
Mighty Heroes Clan
Mighty Heroes Clan
Posts: 44
Joined: 12 Aug 2015 18:04
Has thanked: 9 times
Been thanked: 6 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby Olkimos » 16 Sep 2015 19:12

you can say whatever, just to be against diplomatt)))) how do u know that 90%? when u dont know how many units in trees coz u cant see them on diplomatt's ss?)))))

i think judges has to decide was that against rules and meaning of this rule. and then they will replay this game with same builds coz they didnt play. that's my point of view)

The True Legend
Victory or Death Clan
Victory or Death Clan
User avatar
Posts: 183
Joined: 07 May 2015 03:40
Has thanked: 16 times
Been thanked: 70 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby The True Legend » 16 Sep 2015 19:26

lol Ik what im saying, go look at Wolf channel. You'll see there. Im not going againt anyone, im just saying the truth. The truth is stardomski is entitled to noob boxes (which was done to barac and he didnt quit). And he didnt violate any rules.
The strong is never disturbed by the weak!

Winner of 5 Big Events & #11 in the Rome 2 Leaderboard!!

Administrator at the VODCA Steam Group. Join the Group and Fight for you own Glory!
My Awards
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
ImageImage
Image
Image


Complete Tournament Achievements(R2&ATW)
Rome 2:
1rstThe Last Stand (32)
1rstSons of Macedon (32)
1rstWrath of Barbs (16)
1rstSoutheast Arc (34)
1rstGladiators League S07 (20)
1rstUnit Ban Beta (23)
1rstVODCA R2 Flash#2 (15)
1rstUse it, Lose it (64) (both finalists winners)
2ndWOLF Flash#8 (16)
FinalsNAFT#2 (13) (kicked out by host after beating him)
Semi-FinalsComrade's 2v2 Team Tourny (16) (died out)
Top 8CON 2015 with Epirus(!!!)

Attila:
1rstNAFT July (16)
2ndVODCA ATW Flash#5
3rdBlood and Sand (32)
3rdWind Of Changes (32)
3rdTWCL Winter 2015 (24)
3rdODM Flash#1 (21)
Semi-FinalsUnit Ban Alpha (16) (died out)

The True Legend
Victory or Death Clan
Victory or Death Clan
User avatar
Posts: 183
Joined: 07 May 2015 03:40
Has thanked: 16 times
Been thanked: 70 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby The True Legend » 16 Sep 2015 19:29

https://youtu.be/Yas5TTnH0lg?t=3253
look here, and the b****ing done by blademaster when rules clearly say pike builds are allowed in defense. If anything WOLF wasted stradomski's time by leaving after both agreeing on a set time and then insulting him.
BTW you may think im againt DIplomat but you hate on stradomkski, telling me how hes a fag and all... (and no I have no SS as proof lol, see, i dont save ss of chats lolz).
These users thanked the author The True Legend for the post:
Asseror
The strong is never disturbed by the weak!

Winner of 5 Big Events & #11 in the Rome 2 Leaderboard!!

Administrator at the VODCA Steam Group. Join the Group and Fight for you own Glory!
My Awards
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
ImageImage
Image
Image


Complete Tournament Achievements(R2&ATW)
Rome 2:
1rstThe Last Stand (32)
1rstSons of Macedon (32)
1rstWrath of Barbs (16)
1rstSoutheast Arc (34)
1rstGladiators League S07 (20)
1rstUnit Ban Beta (23)
1rstVODCA R2 Flash#2 (15)
1rstUse it, Lose it (64) (both finalists winners)
2ndWOLF Flash#8 (16)
FinalsNAFT#2 (13) (kicked out by host after beating him)
Semi-FinalsComrade's 2v2 Team Tourny (16) (died out)
Top 8CON 2015 with Epirus(!!!)

Attila:
1rstNAFT July (16)
2ndVODCA ATW Flash#5
3rdBlood and Sand (32)
3rdWind Of Changes (32)
3rdTWCL Winter 2015 (24)
3rdODM Flash#1 (21)
Semi-FinalsUnit Ban Alpha (16) (died out)

Diplomatt
Wolf of Remus Clan
Wolf of Remus Clan
Posts: 33
Joined: 05 May 2015 17:50
Has thanked: 10 times
Been thanked: 15 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby Diplomatt » 16 Sep 2015 19:44

All I have to say to you AK is fuck off

A unit being visible doesn't mean that it isn't in the forest. If admins decide that it isn't a forest camp then ok I will replay same armies but I have shown evidence to support my argument and all I'm getting is 'you can see the units so they're not in the forest' which is a silly argument.
These users thanked the author Diplomatt for the post:
Olkimos
Awards
Image

The True Legend
Victory or Death Clan
Victory or Death Clan
User avatar
Posts: 183
Joined: 07 May 2015 03:40
Has thanked: 16 times
Been thanked: 70 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby The True Legend » 16 Sep 2015 19:53

Dude what do rules say?? They say you cant COVER, not place but cover (Cover means to "put something such as a cloth or lid on top of or in front of (something) in order to protect or conceal it", Conceal not anything else). As you can see, Str's units were not concealed at all by the trees. They were visible to you clearly enough to plan out an attack.
Im sorry but you cant leave a game just like that, and demand a free win. It just doesnt work like that dude.
The strong is never disturbed by the weak!

Winner of 5 Big Events & #11 in the Rome 2 Leaderboard!!

Administrator at the VODCA Steam Group. Join the Group and Fight for you own Glory!
My Awards
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
ImageImage
Image
Image


Complete Tournament Achievements(R2&ATW)
Rome 2:
1rstThe Last Stand (32)
1rstSons of Macedon (32)
1rstWrath of Barbs (16)
1rstSoutheast Arc (34)
1rstGladiators League S07 (20)
1rstUnit Ban Beta (23)
1rstVODCA R2 Flash#2 (15)
1rstUse it, Lose it (64) (both finalists winners)
2ndWOLF Flash#8 (16)
FinalsNAFT#2 (13) (kicked out by host after beating him)
Semi-FinalsComrade's 2v2 Team Tourny (16) (died out)
Top 8CON 2015 with Epirus(!!!)

Attila:
1rstNAFT July (16)
2ndVODCA ATW Flash#5
3rdBlood and Sand (32)
3rdWind Of Changes (32)
3rdTWCL Winter 2015 (24)
3rdODM Flash#1 (21)
Semi-FinalsUnit Ban Alpha (16) (died out)

Diplomatt
Wolf of Remus Clan
Wolf of Remus Clan
Posts: 33
Joined: 05 May 2015 17:50
Has thanked: 10 times
Been thanked: 15 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby Diplomatt » 16 Sep 2015 21:00

Standing under a tree can be classed as being covered by trees. You also contradicted yourself, 'protect or conceal it, Conceal not anything else', you ignore that his units were protected by the trees hmm?

The units are at least partially in the trees, some of them have the majority of the unit in the trees, vision and planning out an attack is irrelevant, being in trees is relevant. I have provided screenshots proving my point.
Awards
Image

The True Legend
Victory or Death Clan
Victory or Death Clan
User avatar
Posts: 183
Joined: 07 May 2015 03:40
Has thanked: 16 times
Been thanked: 70 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby The True Legend » 17 Sep 2015 01:15

Diplomatt wrote:Standing under a tree can be classed as being covered by trees. You also contradicted yourself, 'protect or conceal it, Conceal not anything else', you ignore that his units were protected by the trees hmm?

The units are at least partially in the trees, some of them have the majority of the unit in the trees, vision and planning out an attack is irrelevant, being in trees is relevant. I have provided screenshots proving my point.

it wasnt a tree it was a bush lol. EVen if it was a tree, he was not covered by it as most of the unit was not anywhere near that bush. His units (90%) was not protected by that bush. I can only think a rematch is fair and if you continue leaving the games when his playing style infuriates you then a technical loss should be given to you on that game.
But honestly, I dont really care. I would prefer if you were to win, actually...
The strong is never disturbed by the weak!

Winner of 5 Big Events & #11 in the Rome 2 Leaderboard!!

Administrator at the VODCA Steam Group. Join the Group and Fight for you own Glory!
My Awards
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
ImageImage
Image
Image


Complete Tournament Achievements(R2&ATW)
Rome 2:
1rstThe Last Stand (32)
1rstSons of Macedon (32)
1rstWrath of Barbs (16)
1rstSoutheast Arc (34)
1rstGladiators League S07 (20)
1rstUnit Ban Beta (23)
1rstVODCA R2 Flash#2 (15)
1rstUse it, Lose it (64) (both finalists winners)
2ndWOLF Flash#8 (16)
FinalsNAFT#2 (13) (kicked out by host after beating him)
Semi-FinalsComrade's 2v2 Team Tourny (16) (died out)
Top 8CON 2015 with Epirus(!!!)

Attila:
1rstNAFT July (16)
2ndVODCA ATW Flash#5
3rdBlood and Sand (32)
3rdWind Of Changes (32)
3rdTWCL Winter 2015 (24)
3rdODM Flash#1 (21)
Semi-FinalsUnit Ban Alpha (16) (died out)

Patronus
Via Militera Clan
Via Militera Clan
User avatar
Posts: 432
Joined: 01 May 2015 10:28
Has thanked: 673 times
Been thanked: 142 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby Patronus » 17 Sep 2015 16:42

Правилами не запрещено использовать построение коробкой игроку находящемуся в защите, также не был нарушен запрет на укрытие в лесу более 3/4 армии. Соответственно, техническое поражение не будет присвоено ни одной из сторон. Вы должны переиграть этот бой теме же составами. Дедлайн Вам продлен до 18 сентября.

Rules are allowed to use box if player is defender, also was not broken ban to cover more than 3/4 of the Army in the forest.
Accordingly, a forfeit loss will not be awarded any of the parties. You have to rematch this battle the same builts of army. Deadline extended for you until September 18.

GL HF!

Postscriptum:
Предупреждение: использование нецензурной лексики и оскорбление игроков ведет к дисквалификации с турнира!

Warning: use obscene language and an insult to the players It leads to disqualification from the tournament!
These users thanked the author Patronus for the post:
blood_leopard99
Awards
ImageImage

The True Legend
Victory or Death Clan
Victory or Death Clan
User avatar
Posts: 183
Joined: 07 May 2015 03:40
Has thanked: 16 times
Been thanked: 70 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby The True Legend » 17 Sep 2015 16:53

As expected...
These users thanked the author The True Legend for the post:
blood_leopard99
The strong is never disturbed by the weak!

Winner of 5 Big Events & #11 in the Rome 2 Leaderboard!!

Administrator at the VODCA Steam Group. Join the Group and Fight for you own Glory!
My Awards
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
ImageImage
Image
Image


Complete Tournament Achievements(R2&ATW)
Rome 2:
1rstThe Last Stand (32)
1rstSons of Macedon (32)
1rstWrath of Barbs (16)
1rstSoutheast Arc (34)
1rstGladiators League S07 (20)
1rstUnit Ban Beta (23)
1rstVODCA R2 Flash#2 (15)
1rstUse it, Lose it (64) (both finalists winners)
2ndWOLF Flash#8 (16)
FinalsNAFT#2 (13) (kicked out by host after beating him)
Semi-FinalsComrade's 2v2 Team Tourny (16) (died out)
Top 8CON 2015 with Epirus(!!!)

Attila:
1rstNAFT July (16)
2ndVODCA ATW Flash#5
3rdBlood and Sand (32)
3rdWind Of Changes (32)
3rdTWCL Winter 2015 (24)
3rdODM Flash#1 (21)
Semi-FinalsUnit Ban Alpha (16) (died out)

Olkimos
Mighty Heroes Clan
Mighty Heroes Clan
Posts: 44
Joined: 12 Aug 2015 18:04
Has thanked: 9 times
Been thanked: 6 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby Olkimos » 17 Sep 2015 18:44

Товарищ адвокат, адвокааат!
These users thanked the author Olkimos for the post:
blood_leopard99

happysouls
First Guards Clan
Posts: 4
Joined: 10 Aug 2015 17:35
Been thanked: 3 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby happysouls » 19 Sep 2015 13:39

AK why are you acting as if it's not a big deal that Stradomski forest camped. I have a strange feeling after our game, that you too would be accusing him of breaking/abusing the rules if that happend to you.

Remember when I had to move out of my advantageous (most likely game winning) position, and let you charge me in the rear, during our game (which lasted 1 hour as a result of this)? I had to move out coz you refused to attack me for about 15 minutes. And that wasn't even a proper forest, it was only like 3-4 trees. And the only reason why we were able to settle this between the two of us was due to me not giving a fuck about the result of the battle (I only care about playing a good game).

I'm not trying to come up with an excuse for my loss (maybe a tiny little bit?). You won 1 - 0 with a weaker faction, fair enough ggwp. It was fun (for the first 15min that is). All is good.

BUT...

If me capming, with my 4-5 depleated units ,under like 4 trees made you not want to engage me (what lasted about 15 min.) why are you acting as if what Stradomski did is fine.

IMO Diplomat is right but it doesn't matter since hosts already made their decision. It's just that I was very suprised that you consider it a fair play.
These users thanked the author happysouls for the post:
Olkimos

The True Legend
Victory or Death Clan
Victory or Death Clan
User avatar
Posts: 183
Joined: 07 May 2015 03:40
Has thanked: 16 times
Been thanked: 70 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby The True Legend » 19 Sep 2015 17:06

happysouls wrote:AK why are you acting as if it's not a big deal that Stradomski forest camped. I have a strange feeling after our game, that you too would be accusing him of breaking/abusing the rules if that happend to you.

Remember when I had to move out of my advantageous (most likely game winning) position, and let you charge me in the rear, during our game (which lasted 1 hour as a result of this)? I had to move out coz you refused to attack me for about 15 minutes. And that wasn't even a proper forest, it was only like 3-4 trees. And the only reason why we were able to settle this between the two of us was due to me not giving a fuck about the result of the battle (I only care about playing a good game).

I'm not trying to come up with an excuse for my loss (maybe a tiny little bit?). You won 1 - 0 with a weaker faction, fair enough ggwp. It was fun (for the first 15min that is). All is good.

BUT...

If me capming, with my 4-5 depleated units ,under like 4 trees made you not want to engage me (what lasted about 15 min.) why are you acting as if what Stradomski did is fine.

IMO Diplomat is right but it doesn't matter since hosts already made their decision. It's just that I was very suprised that you consider it a fair play.

you do realize that placing 3 to 4 units in 4 trees is breaking the rules?? And so, I was right to ask you (nicely) to move out and fight it out fairly. Did I threaten you to whine and cry to the host for a free win?? Nope. Did I leave the game as soon as you did that?? Nope. Was I attacking you?? Yep. Missile attack is considered an attack and surrounding you from all sides with a full strength noble horse and 2 units of cap cavs was making me the dominant attacker. A rear charge, to go along a frontal and flanking charge, was just inevitable. Forest camping or not that was my game.
After all, I wasnt the one saying how I (myself) for sure won that game and only had to charge in with my cavs. I only needed you not breaking rules to make sure I would win. And what stradomksi did was nothing close to what you did.
The strong is never disturbed by the weak!

Winner of 5 Big Events & #11 in the Rome 2 Leaderboard!!

Administrator at the VODCA Steam Group. Join the Group and Fight for you own Glory!
My Awards
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
ImageImage
Image
Image


Complete Tournament Achievements(R2&ATW)
Rome 2:
1rstThe Last Stand (32)
1rstSons of Macedon (32)
1rstWrath of Barbs (16)
1rstSoutheast Arc (34)
1rstGladiators League S07 (20)
1rstUnit Ban Beta (23)
1rstVODCA R2 Flash#2 (15)
1rstUse it, Lose it (64) (both finalists winners)
2ndWOLF Flash#8 (16)
FinalsNAFT#2 (13) (kicked out by host after beating him)
Semi-FinalsComrade's 2v2 Team Tourny (16) (died out)
Top 8CON 2015 with Epirus(!!!)

Attila:
1rstNAFT July (16)
2ndVODCA ATW Flash#5
3rdBlood and Sand (32)
3rdWind Of Changes (32)
3rdTWCL Winter 2015 (24)
3rdODM Flash#1 (21)
Semi-FinalsUnit Ban Alpha (16) (died out)

happysouls
First Guards Clan
Posts: 4
Joined: 10 Aug 2015 17:35
Been thanked: 3 times

VM Stradomski vs WOLF Diplomatt

Postby happysouls » 20 Sep 2015 00:45

no I do not realize that mate. I wasn't breaking any rules afaik, you didn't mention that I was breaking the rules either, until now that is.. neither did you ask me to move out, (again, u've never even suggested that I was breaking the rules until now) I did it only in order to avoid wasting more time.

we both had missile units left and you didn't want to trade hits so you pulled back each time I tried to assault you, thats not attacking. Also, full surround of the enemy formation =/= attacking.

'Forest camping or not that was my game.' - really?? If I remember correctly you had about 5 horse riders left at the end of the game? Did you calculate all of it that you are saying it was 'your game''??

but hey, maybe I am wrong and you're right. If anyone gives a shit they can see for themselves, here's the replay.

http://s000.tinyupload.com/index.php?fi ... 8317008773

also, if 'placing 3 to 4 units in 4 trees is breaking the rules??', as you said, then how come, in your opinion what Stradomski did is not breaking the rules? I mean come on, clearly more than 60% of his army WAS placed in the trees.


Return to “Round III”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

cron